Garrett Sweet & Mild is a fine scotch to me. TOPS Sweet is like sniffing cacao and Swisher Cherry isnt cherry at all imho.
I’ve only had one sweet and that was Garrett. I didnt really like it, way too sugary for me. How does Red Seal compare? I found a place that carries it and was thinking of giving sweets another try.
Red Seal is more of a naturally sweet tobacco atleast that’s what I get out of it
Tube Rose is one of my favs, and so is in fact also Navy Sweet from Swisher. None of the two will rip your head off, unless you seriously abuse them :o)