I’d probably be fine with Toque Natural, but SG Irish D over #22.
@enten-eller SG’s is a bit too sweet for me, but also very nice. I prefer more bitter taste though.
I like bitter too, but I think the little extra smokiness of the #22 might be too much (all the time) if that was all I had. I’d manage w/it though. 
But yeah, I mostly prefer bitter over sweet. One of the less smokey americans come to mind. I’ve found that even stored well and in the nice tins, F&T HDT loses strength after a couple of years or so.
I would choose Ozona Cherry without a moment of thinking. They say every snuffer is looking for the perfect snuff(for them). Well, seems like it’s Ozona Cherry for me.
@Ardrasath how many tins would you have to take along to a desert island? 3 or 4 a day right?
Of course not. I would have to take the whole Pöschl factory with me.