What are your top five favorite menthol/mint snuff, not necessarily in order of preference? I was trying to figure it out for myself, and it’s very hard, much more difficult than with other varieties for some reason. Maybe because there are so many out there. In any case: WoS SM Blue WoS SM 500 Hedges McC O&G McC Supermint WoS Crumbs of Comfort Toque Peppermint See, even I couldn’t keep it to 5!

Zip CM O&G SM Blue I couldn’t even reach 5! I don’t use menthol snuffs much and when I do I invariably go for the ones which also have camphor in them.

WoS Crumbs Of Comfort McChrystal’s SuperMint WoS Xtra Crumbs Of Comfort Ozona President Poschl Apricot I’m not a lover of menthols, but I love mint

nobody said wilsons cherry menthol!? also: crumbs of comfort ozona president mchrystals og gletscher prise

1. Hedges 2) J.H. Wilson’s Medicated No. 99 3) McChrystal’s Supermint 4) Toque Peppermint 5) McChrystal’s English Menthol 6) Swisher/Helme Railroad Mills Checkerberry (Because someone has to mention this one. It’s neither menthol nor mint, but it vaguely belongs in the “medicated” category.)

oh wow, how could I forget RR Mills Checkerberry, I love that stuff, in fact, I’m going to take some right now. Good call kjoerup

medi 99 - good call - (reaches for his tin of)

WoS Crumbs of Comfort WoS Country Mint WoS Peppermint McC Supermint Toque Peppermint All of which have no menthol, just mint. I must admit, I do quite like Prime MInister which is menthol, but I already named 5.

Oh drat. I forgot Zwiefacher. The only German menthol I really liked.

O&G Sturco Hedges L260 WoS Crumbs of Comfort Gawith Apricot

In no particular order: O&G J&H Medicated No. 99 JIP Hedges Highland Ice

I find the Dholakia Medicated to be very good, with a pleasant sweetish taste, and a nice cooling menthol, which is almost just right. Also Sparrow Cool, has a very nice tobacco taste, with a really unique menthol addition, that highlights it rather than overtakes it. I also like the menthol blending of 5 Photo Himalaya, and the Sun Snuffs. So… I guess my top 5 would be from those, but then I also like the fruity menthols of Wilsons, though their menthol is usually of a more peircing level.

GH CM WOS SM Blue WOS Peppermint WOS Honey Menthol WOS Vanilla Ice --More eucalyptus than vanilla.

Favorites: McC O&G Hedges L260 WoS SM Gold Sparrow Cool WoS Raspberry Checkerberry I haven’t really got on with WoS Crumbs of Comfort, Country Mint, or Toque Peppermint. It’s not that I don’t like them, I do. But not as much as those above.

Wilsons Honey Menthol (by quite some way my favourite menthol, I always have this one on hand in bulk) McChrystals Original and Genuine Samuel Gawith CCC (a quite unique flavour along with the menthol) Wilsons SM 500 Wilsons SM Brown

Top 5 in no order: Hedges L260 McC O&G Gawith Hoggarth CM McC Highland Ice McC Sturco Toque Menthol, Gawith Hoggarth Special Medicated, Spartan, McC JIP! and Samuel Gawith Dr Vereys Plus would complete my top 10.

Taxi Rock, Red Bull, Gletscherprise, WoS Blue, O&G

WoS Honey Menthol O&G McC Highland Ice Gawith Apricot Gletscher Prise

Mc Chystlas O&G J&H WilsonsMedicated 99 WOS SM Blue Hedges WOS Ice Licorice

Ice Licorice, Honey Menthol, Hedges, Lowenprise, S.M. 500

That was a quick change of heart, Juxtaposer.

Dr. Rumney’s Export, Zwiefacher, Astromina, S.M. Brown. Crumbs of comfort

I can’t keep up with you. I hope you can keep up with yourself.

Gawith Apricot, Jubilaums, Toque Peppermint, Alpina, Manjul.

Ooh. Alpina. Forgot about alpina. (reaches for alpina)

Toque Peppermint Hedges L260 WoS Extra Menthol Poshl Red Bull WoS Crumbs Of Comfort

O&G Hedges Toque Peppermint WoS Super Menthol WoS Honey Menthol Similar to a few other lists but what the heck. I would have Poschl Red Bull as no. 6. Stefan

Mullins & Westley Keen Scented WoS S.M. ---------------I cant believe that this one is not as popular as some of the rest, I think its very very close to M&W Keen Scented which is my All Time Favorite! Packards club Med 99 red bull Hedges McC English Menthol O&G Highland Ice Toque Menthol WoS S.M. 500 WoS Super Menthol WoS Extra Menthol

Well, have only just had my first ever Rumneys Export, so it didn’t make my list above. It does now! Lovely snuff!

I forgot Toque Blueberry menthol - I LOVE that one!