Hi, I see some top 10, top 5 lists went on, but they were mixed in brand and limited to a number. I’m building up my snuff repertoire throughout the brands so I’m asking your favourite lists by brand. Since it will be by brand, I didn’t want to push you hard and thought that 3 will suffice. If you want to extend, then you’re most wellcome, Here’s my top 3 by brand, among my tiny inventory. TOQUE 1-Vanilla 2-Original 3-Chocolate POSCHL 1-Schmalzler Doppelaroma 2-Andechs Spezial 3-Gawith Apricot and that’s it 
The user and all related content has been deleted.
McChrystal’s 1. Clove 2. Violet 3. Mild Lemon Wilson’s 1. Jasmine 2. Crumbs of Comfort 3. Royal George Toque 1. Toffee 2. Whisky and Honey 3. St. Clements Gawith Hoggarth 1. Dry Orange 2. Ambassador 3. Tia Maria Samuel Gawith 1. Cob Dark 2. Honey 3. Black Coffee Poschl 1. President 2. Raspberry 3. Cola Bespoke 1. Christmas Joy 2. Gin & Tonic
Here are my favorites of different brands. The flavors are in no particular order. Samuel Gawith 1. Black Coffee 2. No.1 High Mill 3. Honey 4. SP Scotch Wilsons 1. Strawberry 2. Best SP 3. Tom Buck 4. Best Dark Toque 1. Raspberry 2. Original 3. Blueberry 4. Pomegranate Frederick Tranters 1. Regency 2. Irish D.H. Toast #20 3. Citrus 4. Jockey Club Fribourg & Treyer 1. Seville 2. Old Paris 3. Kendal Brown 4. High Dry Toast Bespoke 1. Gin & Tonic 2. Martian Rose 3. Stephans Tipple 4. Christmas Joy Dholakia 1. Kamal 2. Manjul 3. Sparrow Green 4. Swiss Chocolate McChrystals 1. Raspberry 2. Hop 3. SP 4. Apricot Swisher 1. Strawberry 2. Navy Scotch 3. Square 4. Railroad Mills Scotch Conwood 1. Levi Garrett 2. Tube Rose 3. W.E. Garrett Scotch 4. Honest UST 1. Rooster 2. Red Seal 3. Bruton 4. CC Poschl 1. Kloster Andechs 2. Alpina 3. Apricot 4. Gletscherprise QWS 1. Jasmine 2. Sandalwood 3. Apricot 4. Irish Coffee De Kralingse 1. Macuba 2. A/P 3. Prins Regent 4. Latakia AO 1860 Gawith Hoggarth 1. Whisky 2. Sea Breezes 3. Dry Orange 4. Cinnamon
I’ve only been snuffing for a few months and I don’t have 200 snuffs around like Trout! I always watch his lists so I know what to try next. Here are my current standings: Toque 1. Whiskey & Honey Toast 2. Grapefruit 3. Peanut Butter Wilsons 1. S.M. 500 2. Peppermint 3. Aniseed Extra Samuel Gawith 1. Kendall Brown Special 2. Irish D Original 3. SP Scotch or SP No. 1 High Mill (tie for 3rd place) Fribourg & Treyer 1. Princes 2. HDT 3. Seville
Okay… I’ll play. Fribourg & Treyer 1. Dr J R Justice 2. High Dry Toast 3. Princes Special Samuel Gawith 1. KB Special 2. Irish ‘D’ Light 3. No. 1 High Mill Toque 1. Whisky and Honey 2. Original 3. Toast and Marmalade De Kralingse 1. Latakia Ao 1860 2. A/P 3. Oranje Gawith Hoggarth 1. Kendal Brown 2. Dry Orange 3. There is no number three… McChrystals 1. O&G 2. SP 3. Stammheimer Hopfen Schnupf Pöschl 1. Schmalzer A Brazil 2. Perlesreuter Waldler 3. Schmalzler D Doppelaroma Brazil Bernard 1. Brasil Feinst 2. All the rest of their Schmalzlers! 3. Gekachelter Virginie Wilson’s of Sharrow 1. Irish High Toast No 22 2. Best SP 3. Best Dark G. Smith & Sons 1. Golden Cardinal 2. Cafe Royale 3. (Haven’t tried any others) Ludwig Sternecker 1. Echt Fresko 2. Fresko 3. Straubinger Schmalzler Conwood 1. W.E. Garrett Scotch 2. W.E. Garrett Sweet & Mild 3. (Haven’t tried any others) US Smokeless Tobacco 1. Rooster 2. Bruton Scotch 2. (Haven’t tried any others) Swisher 1. Railroad Mills Scotch 2. Square 3. Ralph’s J&H Wilson 1. Top Mill No. 1 2. S.P. No.1 3. There is no number three…
TOQUE 1) Whisky & Honey 2) St Clements 3) Grapefruit BERNARD’S 1) Klostermischung 2) Zwiefacher 3) Altbaperischer DHOLAKIA 1) Manjul 2) Kamal 3) Sparrow Green WILSON’S OF SHARROW 1) Tom Buck 2) Irsisk HDT No 22 3) Burgundy POSCHL 1) Gawith Apricot 2) Ozona President 3) Ozona Raspberry
Agh, I left out DHOLAKIA SWISS CHOCOLATE!!!
The user and all related content has been deleted.
The first snuff of the day is my favorite. My mid day binge snuff is my second favorite and my third favorite brand is the last snuff of the day.
Sorry to resurrect an old thread. Here are my top snuffs by manufacturers I have tried so far: Samuel Gawith: 1) SP no. 1 High Mill 2) Scotch SP 3) Golden Glow Toque: 1) Whisky and Honey 2) Bourbon 3) Espresso Wilsons: 1) Jockey Club 2) Royal George 3) Strasbourg Gawith Hoggarth 1) Western Glory 2) Kendal Brown 3) Can’t think of another, as I haven’t tried many McChrystals 1) Original and Genuine 2) Hopfen Schnupf 3) Violet F&T 1) Dr J R Justice 2) French Carotte 3) Bordeaux But no doubt as I try more this will change.
In no particular order: Toque: Champagne Peanut Butter SG Poschl: Cola Packards Apricot McChrystals: O&G Violet Raspberry Wilson’s: Lemon Grove Irish Toast #22 Strawberry Swisher: Navy Scotch Wild Cherry Superior Scotch US Smokeless: Rooster DeVoe CC Dholakia: Swiss Chocolate Bernards: Brasil Doppelt Fermentiert Klostermischung Zwiefacher Bespoke: Martian Rose
Toque: Toast and Marmelade Peanut Butter Original Wilson of Sharrow Best Dark Best SP Grand Cairo Bernards: Brasil Doppelt Fermentiert Brasil Feinst Feinster Kownoer Samuel Gawiths: SP Scotch Black Coffee Banana Fribourg & Treyer Old Paris High Dry Toast Kendal Brown Dholakia: Aniseed Menthol Kamal Manjul Gawith Hoggarth: Kendal Brown J&H Wilson: SP N 1 Top Mill Medicated n 99 QWS: Apricot Smokers Blend Poschl: Gletscherprise Gawith Apricot Redford Premium Bespoke : Gin e Tonic
Shocked that nobody put Spanish Gem under Toque, yet. Toque: Spanish Gem Whiskey & Honey Original Wilson: Irish High Dry Toast #22 Tom Buck QWS Apricot Smokers Blend Poschl: Packard’s Club Gawith Apricot President Dholakia Sparrow Cool Swiss Chocolate Aniseed Menthol Haven’t really tried enough to add more than that…yet!
_Shocked that nobody put Spanish Gem under Toque, yet_cstokes4 did, as SG. I haven’t had enough yet to compile this sort of list. I’ll have to think about it for a few days, some will have to be left blank
Ah, didn’t notice it said SG.
Toque - 1. Original 2. Toast and Maramalade 3. Vanilla WoS - 1. Best SP 2. Rose 3. Royal George Dholakia - 1. Aniseed Menthol 2. Sparrow Cool 3. Kamal Dholakia Contract Brands For Mr Snuff - 1. Fubar Grunt 2. Fubar Rum 3. Fubar Apricot (grew to love these after giving them a second chance!) Fribourg and Treyer - 1. HDT 2. Princes 3. Seville
So far… Toque: 1. St. Clements 2. Spanish Gem 3. Quit … And it’s just occurred to me that Toque is the only brand I’ve tried enough of to have a real opinion on. 
My favourites are changing every 2-3 weeks. Here my actuall results: F&T: Princess Special Bordeaux Seville Toque: Original Quit WoS: Honey&Menthol McChristals: O&G Highland Ice Mullins&Westley’s: Covent Snuff keen Scented Covent mature crumbled S&G: SP High Mill No. 1
I answered this one back in December, but my collection has doubled and my favorites have changed since then so I’ll give it another go. McChrystal’s 1. Clove 2. SP 3. Sturco Wilson’s 1. Jasmine 2. Royal George 3. SP Silver Toque 1. Toast & Marmalade 2. Toffee 3. Whiskey & Honey Gawith Hoggarth 1. Sea Breezes 2. Spartan 3. Ambassador Samuel Gawith 1. Golden Glow 2. Dr. Verey’s Plus 3. Zip Poschl 1. Raspberry 2. Robby’s Top Mint 3. Gletscher Prise Extra Bespoke 1. Christmas Joy 2. Gin & Tonic 3. Stephen’s Tipple F&T 1. Bordeaux 2. Seville 3. Macouba J&H Wilson 1. Medicated No 99 2. SP No 1 3. Top Mill No 1 Dholakia 1. Ganga 2. Kamal 3. Rockit Cherry Pop Bernard 1. Zwiefacher 2. Klostermischung 3. Amostrinha Forgot an American top three. 1. Honey Bee 2. Three Thistles Strong 3. Helme Wild Cherry