I agree. Toasts and SPs are my mainstays, and St. Clements fits in well with my SP rotation. I really would love to see Roderick make St. Clements using the toast base. That snuff would be out of this world.
I really love the Lime and Marmalade Toasts. From amongst the non-Toasts my favorites are St. Clements followed by the Raspberry. I eat grapefruit daily and with pleasure to potentiate a medication I take, but I found the Toque Grapefruit to be a little too subtle for my taste. Unlike the OP, I prefer my snuff to be more complex, which is why I’m especially fond of the Fruit Toasts and the St. Clement.
For me it’s the Pomegranate or Blueberry. Just dived into the Pomegranate for the first time in a long while and, yup, it’s as great as I remembered!