I’ve only tried the Toque and Gawith. Tend to stray away from the menthol but both are good once in awhile

In my last order I have 2, I’ll try to report back.

Hmmm , I haven’t tried them all but I ve had a few 

Poschl Gawith Cola - A little bit of sweetener , a bit of menthol and a nice bit of cola . I like this a lot , perhaps  a ‘beginners’ snuff but none the worse for it I ve bought a lot of these and will continue to have a few. 

Stok Cola Drink .(discontinued) . In a similar mould to the Poschl but not as well rounded . I liked it okay but I ve not bought it again.

Blast Cola Champagne . Nice sweet coke flavour , Toquesque ,  needed hydrating and airing to awaken the scent . Enjoy it but haven’t used pots of it 

Sam Gawith Cola(discontinued)  . Strong scented … the scent runs on in my nose from Cola to lavender or something but it’s a very takable snuff . Personally I have used it in mixes more than straightup . Will miss this from the SG lineup . May buy a few to store post May . 

I’ve only tried those two, and I like Toque best.  The Gawith is heavier, Toque actually seems fizzy like pop. 

@leman

I just got a toque order in the mail today, and all of them had a strong sent. The Toque Quit, smells just like my Toque Coke, thinking that maybe I got a bad tin from Mr. Snuff.

Wilson’s Cola is pretty good. The scenting is not overpowering, and fades fast, leaving the typical mild tobacco scent. Overall, it’s okay, but I’m not a big fan. I got it in one of the WoS 12 packs of 5g tins.

Tried Poshel’s silver last night, Not sure what I think yet, will need to give it another try, but the menthol was interesting, the cola sent was off.

I also tried Samuel Gawith cola, but that was just bland, but that could be because of the tapbox.

Will be trying my own bend once the essence arrives. My base will be Toque Natural Toast and maybe a second with the berry.

I tried the Gawith Silver again and I have to say, you have to have a really good imagination to smell cola. I get super sweet menthol with some raspberries. I could stretch and say cherry coke.

It’s a pleasant, easy snuff. But I just don’t get the cola.

Did a review of Samuel Gawith cola. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N-Cy2fnV3xY&sns=em

I have the Toque and a little bit disappointed: a weak scent that dies very quickly and not much nicotine at all. It was fresh as (ammonia smell before airing) so it was not due to it being stale.

Any “Cola” snuff that I’ve tried never gives you what your expecting. Same goes with the Bubblegum. Even my homemade bubblegum and cola snuff is disappointing.?

Toque Coke’s aroma is beyond weak. I can’t even tell if it’s even cola or not.

I also tried WoS Cola and the same applies. No cola scent what-so-ever.

Been disappointed with the cola’s as I LOVE cola flavored things.

i have been underwhelmed with the cola snuffs i have tried. Sam G, WoS and Toque. For me the SG is too cloying and artificial, the WoS is more like root beer and the Toque was “weak”. The 2 SGs and the toque  i have went straight into my “crazy Marcos”  now at 150g  jar of snuffs i don’t care for–this snuff i will store for a rainy day and use if snuff is someday banned and i run out of everything else   the wos  i am still sampling but it will probably end up in the aforementioned jar, 

Doing one’s own sounds like a good idea, could one use the concentrate found at beer supply stores for making homemade pop?

Speaking of colas, any of you drink “Thum’s Up” from India. My favorite cola–the nearby Indian store stocks it

Only real cola scent I had was in a non-tobacco snuff: Tiger Snuff Cola… that is like gummy cola candies. You can mix some in with other snuff and it still holds its flavor. Toque Ginger is what I mixed it with.

@marco - Im from Mumbai, India. I can’t believe you get Thumbs Up over there. People use it as a mixer too with rum / whiskey here in India. Pretty popular. :) 

Yeah, Thums up in Salt Lake City ,utah : now if only they had the Indian snuffs as well

Get some cola extract. Soak your snuff in it for a day, dry it out and try it. I’m sure it will be better than what you paid for as a “Cola” snuff. IMO.

@nicmizer where do you get cola extract ? Are you talking about the syrup ? That would just make your snuff super sticky. 

This I get locally but can find it online from many places. http://shop.greatfermentations.com/product/homebrew-cola-soda-extract/homebrew-soda-extracts https://store.homebrewheaven.com/mobile/soda-pops-c44.aspx

Talking about cola snuffs, how is everyone’s experience with Dholakia’s Cola and Champagne?

Nicmizer, do you mean actually soak in the extract or adding a few drops?how far would one of those bottles go [in terms of grams of snuff?}  i suppose one one use a plain tobacco such as toque natural…

@marco indirectly infuse the flavor with a paper towel soaked in the extract suspended atop a sealed container.

thanks–will try soon

Use this same technique for my banana fostner and dark chocolate homemade snuff. All with plain(natural) tobacco.

@nicmizer - what did you use for the dark chocolate? 

http://www.silvercloudestates.com/index.aspx Give a look back at the DIY scent topic

I found that the Blast Cola Champagne is the closest I’ve found so far to a true cola snuff.

I’ve tried WoS Cola and Toque Coke both with no noticeable cola scent.

@N1THC 

Is the Blast snuff real tobacco snuff ?

I got a Toque Coke and a Silver Dollar cola in the mail today, will get back here with impressions. 

@yisraeldov 

Yup! It’s brown in color and on an Indian Export website I found the below information:

"Blast Snuff is Developed for Seasoned Snuffer So that They Can Enjoy Tobacco in Real Form. "

Blast and Wow snuffs are made by Dholakia and are tobacco snuffs

Can i have a link to that export site?

https://youtu.be/_1Hed7GU7zk

I’ve just finished a 10g tin which I’ve dipped into occasionally over a few years. The scent faded slightly over time, but retained the flavour to the last pinch. Not quite a true cola scent, but still a very pleasant snuff.

@Roderick sadly no I left a review on your site (which wasn’t published) which was critical of how weak the cola scent was. I enjoy most of the snuffs of yours that I have tried but I was expecting much more rrom this and was disappointed.

I’ll do it again along with some positive reviews All reviews I write on the web are honest and courteous. As you say one must moderate for trolls and hate but constructive criticism is beneficial. I’ll give you the pointers though here.A very nice sweet cola/caramel aroma on first sniff but fades almost immediately. Unlike some others of yours I don’t get any base tobacco warmth at all or much nicotine. It is lke sniffing lightly coke scented cornflower to me. Not down to freshness either as it had to be aired overnight due to ammonia smell. Maybe up the concentration of the coke scent and use a stronger, richer tobacco. It’s horses for courses so maybe you can stick with this recipe (some newbies especially don’t want a snuff that blows their head off) and do a Coke Extra maybe as a limited esition to test the water? For example I did not rate your original but love the SP which is stronger and fresher with the citrus. It’s good you are taking this onboard though Roderick. I’ll try another tin when you have made another batch maybe.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T_krtjkWbJY

@Roderick was the Coke ever turned up in strength? I ask because I find it and SD Cola having the perfect amount of aroma. But I don’t smoke and avoid scotches to protect my sense of smell. Someone mentioned the other day again SD Cola not having an aroma but it’s my wife’s single most favorite

@ar47 I’m confused. How do scotches damage one’s sense of smell?

@Zanaspus that’s my observation and subsequently formed belief, subject to influence (I’m willing to listen)

Toque Coke was what got me into snuff. I should pick up some bulk sometime. First USA W&H though. I like the higher nicotine levels. If I’m remembering correctly mine had a decent coke aroma, I did love it.

@ar47 My only thought is that you’ve only had the heavy “barbecue” ones like, say Three Thistle. Those can mess with the schnozz for sure. But, the more moderate ones like Rooster or Standard I find quite lovely and very nostril neutral. Just my two cents.